Athletes are listed alphabetically by last name

Shalen Guilliams
Special Mention All-Ohio (2021-2022)
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2020-2021)

Andie Heffelfinger
Special Mention All-Ohio (2014-2015)
Special Mention All-Ohio (2013-2014)

Kim Herman
3rd Team All-Ohio (1995-1996)
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (1994-1995)

Suzanne Johnson
Special Mention All-Ohio (1997-1998)

Becky Orchard
2nd Team All-Ohio (2009-2010)
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2008-2009)

Celeste Ryman
1st Team All-Ohio (2018-2019)
2nd Team All-Ohio (2017-2018)

Emily Seboe
1st Team All-Ohio (2019-2020)

Alexis VanHorn
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2011-2012)
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2010-2011)

Corri Vermilya
State Player of the Year (2022-2023)
1st Team All-Ohio (2021-2022)
Special Mention All-Ohio (2020-2021)

Grace Vermilya
2nd Team All-Ohio (2020-2021)
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2019-2020)

Nikki Weber
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2018-2019)
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2016-2017)

Misty Wells
Special Mention All-Ohio (1991-1992)