Athletes are listed alphabetically by last name

Brian Allerding
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2001-2002)

Richard “Dick” Armstrong
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (1944-1945)

Tom Christopher
1st Team All-Ohio (1940-1941)

Tom Dennison
1st Team All-Ohio (1955-1956)

Jacob Gessner
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2020-2021)

Kyle Gillette
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2004-2005)

Shane Humphrey
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2003-2004)

Andy Kanzig
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (1992-1993)

Trevor Mowery
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2011-2012)

Dick Porter
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (1950-1951)

Russel Reynolds
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (1974-1975)

Trevor Scott
3rd Team All-Ohio (2004-2005)

Earl Stitzlein
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (1970-1971)

Shawn Swindall
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (2015-2016)

Andy Van Horn
1st Team All-Ohio (2002-2003)

Marion Zody
2nd Team All-Ohio (1952-1953)
Honorable Mention All-Ohio (1951-1952)